Home
New Store Coming Soon! 2056 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg OH  43068
OUR PIZZAS
 
Small
Medium
Large
CHEESE ONLY
$8.50
10.00
$13.00
1 Item
9.50
11.25
14.50
2 Item
10.50
12.50
16.00
Additional Items
1.00
1.25
1.50
Extra Sauce
0.50
0.75
1.00
 
EVERYTHING PIZZA
(Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Banana Peppers)
$13.50
$16.25
$20.50
       
VEGGIE PIZZA
(Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Onions, Black Olives)
$13.25
$16.00
$19.00
       
MEATY PIZZA
(Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Ham, Meatball, Bacon)
$13.99
$16.75
$19.99
       
ISLAND PIZZA
(Capocolla Ham, Pineapple, Cinnamon)
$10.50
$12.50
$16.00
* no substitutions can be made for specialty pizzas *
 
OUR TOPPINGS
Pepperoni Black Olives Banana Peppers
Mushroom Green Olives Pineapple
Italian Sausage Fresh Tomatos Jalapenos
Onion Fresh Garlic Meatball
Green Peppers Anchovies Salami
Capocolla Ham Extra Cheese Bacon
 
OUR SALADS
PAPA ROTOLO'S CHEF SALAD
(Tossed Salad with Capocolla Ham, Pepperoni, Banana Peppers & Provolone Cheese)
$5.00
 
MAMA ROTOLO'S TOSSED SALAD
(Lettuce, Tomato & Italian Dressing)
Small
$3.00
Large
$4.00
 
"PICCOLO PIATTO" / SMALL PLATES
MINI PIZZA ( 7" cheese or any 1 Item )
$5.99
MINI PASTA (Spaghetti or Rigatoni, 1 roll)
$2.99
MINI CHEF SALAD (Lettuce, Capocolla Ham, Provolone Cheese, Pepperoni, Banana Peppers)
$2.99
MINI MEATBALL SUB (1 Meatball on a Roll with Provolone Cheese)
$2.99
MINI ITALIAN SUB (Provolone Cheese, Salami, Capocolla Ham, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomato, Banana Pepper on a Roll)
$2.99
MINI VEGGIE SUB (Provolone Cheese, and Vegetables on a Roll)
$2.99
MINI PIZZA SUB (Pizza sauce, Provolone Cheese and 1 Item)
$2.99
 
OUR DINNERS
HOME-MADE LASAGNA
$7.50
RIGATONI WITH 1 MEATBALL
$7.00
HOME-MADE SPAGHETTI:
With 1 Meatball
$7.00
With Meat Sauce
$7.50
With Mushrooms
$7.50
Baked with Provolone Cheese
$8.00
** Above Dinners Include: Small Salad, 2 Rolls and Our Special Blend of Grated Cheese **

ADD A MEATBALL
$1.50
 
FAMILY DINNERS
FAMILY LASAGNA serves 4
$22.00
FAMILY SPAGHETTI
$18.00
FAMILY RIGATONI
$18.00
BAKED with Provolone Cheese
$20.50
** Above Pasta Dinners Include: 4 Meatballs, Large Salad, 4 Rolls, and Our Special Blend of Grated Cheese **

ADD A MEATBALL
$1.50
 
OUR SUBS
ITALIAN SUB
(Provolone Cheese, Salami, Pepperoni, Banana Peppers, Capcolla Ham, Lettuce, Tomato)
$5.25
SUPER SUB
(Italian Sub with Extra Ham, Salami and Provolone Cheese)
$6.25

VEGGIE SUB
(Provolone Cheese, Mushrooms, Onion, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Tomato)

$5.25
MEATBALL SUB
(3 Meatballs on a Sub Bun)
$5.25
with Provolone Cheese
$6.00
PIZZA SUB
(Pizza sauce, Provolone cheese and Pepperoni on a Sub Bun)
$5.25
GARLIC BREAD
$2.50
with Provolone Cheese
$3.00
 
MAMA ROTOLO'S SAUCE
SPAGHETTI SAUCE
(Pint / Quart)
$3.00 / $5.00
MEAT SAUCE
(Pint / Quart)
$4.25 / $6.50
Visit Us At Our Five Locations